In your opinion, what is the most important aspect of a game's design, and why?
Understanding the Question
When an interviewer asks, "In your opinion, what is the most important aspect of a game's design, and why?", they're probing not just for your personal philosophy on game design but also for your understanding of what makes a game engaging, fun, and commercially successful. This question is open-ended and subjective; there isn't a single correct answer. However, your response can reveal your priorities as a game designer, your understanding of game mechanics, player experience, narrative, aesthetics, or any other element you consider crucial.
Interviewer's Goals
The interviewer has several objectives in mind when asking this question:
-
Assessing Your Understanding of Game Design: They want to see if you have a deep and nuanced understanding of the various elements that contribute to a game's design and how they interconnect to create a cohesive experience.
-
Gauging Your Priorities: Your answer will indicate what you prioritize in game design—whether it's player engagement, storytelling, visual art, mechanics, or something else. This helps the interviewer understand how you might fit into their team and contribute to projects.
-
Evaluating Your Critical Thinking: By asking why you believe a certain aspect is the most important, the interviewer is also checking your ability to critically analyze game design elements and defend your viewpoints with logical reasoning.
-
Understanding Your Creative Vision: Your response can provide insights into your creative vision and how you approach the game design process, showcasing your creativity and problem-solving skills.
How to Approach Your Answer
When preparing your answer, consider the following steps:
-
Choose Your Focus: Select an aspect of game design you are passionate about and can discuss confidently. It might be something you excel at or have had significant experience with.
-
Justify Your Choice: Prepare to explain why you believe this aspect is crucial to a game's design. Use examples from popular games or your own work to illustrate your points.
-
Connect to Broader Impacts: Show how your chosen aspect affects other elements of game design and the player's experience. Discuss its role in the success of a game.
-
Reflect on Trends: If relevant, mention how industry trends influence the importance of your chosen aspect.
-
Personalize Your Answer: Share personal anecdotes or experiences that demonstrate your relationship with this aspect of game design.
Example Responses Relevant to Game Designer
Here are two example responses to guide you:
Example 1: Player Engagement
"In my opinion, the most important aspect of a game's design is creating deep and meaningful player engagement. This encompasses everything from the mechanics and challenge level to the narrative and emotional resonance. For instance, in The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, the open-world design and physics-based puzzles engage players by encouraging exploration and experimentation. I believe that when players are genuinely engaged, they're more likely to have a memorable experience, recommend the game to others, and become fans of the franchise. In my previous projects, focusing on engagement has led to higher player retention rates and positive feedback."
Example 2: Cohesive Narrative
"I believe the most important aspect of a game's design is its ability to tell a cohesive and compelling story. A well-crafted narrative can elevate a game from being merely entertaining to being truly impactful and memorable. For example, The Last of Us series is renowned for its narrative depth, character development, and emotional storytelling, which have all contributed to its critical and commercial success. In my work, I strive to integrate narrative elements seamlessly with gameplay to enhance the player's emotional investment and overall experience."
Tips for Success
- Be Specific: Choose a specific aspect rather than a broad category to show depth in your understanding.
- Use Examples: Referencing well-known games that exemplify your point can make your answer more compelling.
- Show Passion: Let your enthusiasm for game design and your chosen aspect shine through in your response.
- Be Prepared for Follow-Up Questions: Your answer might lead to more detailed questions about your experiences or opinions, so be ready to dive deeper.
- Stay Informed: Keep abreast of current trends and debates in the game design community to inform your perspective.
By thoughtfully preparing your answer to this question, you can demonstrate your expertise, articulate your design philosophy, and show your potential as a valuable addition to the game design team.